Criminal Law Neccessity

DC00087870 Criminal Law Question atomic number 53 Rv Quayle, A-G reader (No 2 of 2004) 2006 1 ALL ER 988 (CA) Within English constabulary the defense force of need helps to recognise that from time to time in that location rat be certain situations which recollect a persons action may humble they afford to break the law. withal, in that respect have been very a few(prenominal) studys in which this vindication has stood within the eyes of the law and courts. The courts have been extremely cautious in allowing necessity to become a defence as a view it as something resembling to a Pandoras Box. maestro Denning himself once said that necessity would open a portal which no man could shut. (Heaton 2004.) some different than self defence on that point are three other defences which could maybe be viewed as a necessary situation. These cigaret be Duress by threat, duress of circumstance and necessity. (Herring 2006.) One of the earliest trial in which necessit y was utilise as a defence was the case of R V Dudley and Stephens (1884) 14 QBD 273. There were four peck enthrallwrecked on a inadequate gravy holder after their ship had sunk in the mellowed seas. They spent 20 age on the open boat six of which they spent without either food or water. Fearing they efficacy soon die Dudley and Stevens resolute that they would kill the cabin male child who was already very disadvantageously and eat him.

Although it was Dudley and Stevens who committed the crime all three used his body to eat and drink. However they were rescued four old age later and upon there return t o England where infact charged with murder. ! They used the defence of necessity. The court govern that the cleanup of the boy was not a matter of necessity and as they had infact killed the boy intentionally they were sheepish of murder. The men argued that the killing of the boy was indeed the lesser of ii evils however there defence failed and they were sentenced to death although this was changed to DC00087870 six months imprisonment. The family unit of Lords have departed on to used this case as the one which sets rout the general rule necessity is not a defence to...If you want to get a total essay, order it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper